People love sports. Whether you enjoy playing on a workplace team, attending games at the ballpark, or obsessively following your fantasy squad, there is no doubt that sports are a great unifier. They bring together communities, they spark conversation, and they bring interest to our daily lives. As ubiquitous as they can be, have you considered that we might be overlooking an opportunity to learn from these sports we love? I believe taking inspiration from the wonderful world of sports can equip us to be better government leaders.
Want to be a champion? Want to turn your workplace team into a dynasty for the ages? Here are three key areas where we can learn from our favorite coaches, players, and sports personalities:
John Madden: Ultimate Plain Language Champion?
Okay, so maybe John Madden wasn’t always the clearest communicator around, but this much is true: sports commentators are a prime example of plain language in action. Need proof? Listen to a sports broadcast on the radio. Clear and efficient communication is the lifeblood of these professionals. The best of the best — from Howard Cosell to Bob Costas — are natural communicators with a gift for conveying information.
Who are government’s sports commentators, the people who break it down simply and efficiently for readers, watchers, and listeners? You may argue that sports are more basic and easier to describe than the work we do. I would argue the difference is minimal. Our leading sports voices could get lost talking about the mechanics of throwing a 99 mile-per-hour fastball or the detailed spacing behind a basketball team’s offensive schemes. They dive into some of these intricacies at times, but they never lose sight of the viewers’ needs.
What would a typical sports broadcast sound like if the commentators described the action like government organizations often talk about their programs and services? Even John Madden at his most random and incoherent might have more clarity than that. We are all capable of being government’s sportscasters. We owe it to ourselves to take a page from this playbook when talking and writing about the work we do.
Moneyball: A Case Study in Performance Measurement
We are rapidly approaching the end of the state fiscal year where I work, which means one thing: It’s performance measurement season. Strategic planning and goal setting for the next fiscal year are the order of the day. Real talk: these tasks have not always come easy for me. Perhaps you can relate. It can be a struggle to set appropriate goals, to decide what to measure, and to move away from measuring activity and outputs and toward measuring outcomes.
For me, sports became a lens through which to better understand and practice the art of performance measurement. More specifically, sports statistics became a natural analog for understanding how government can measure its performance.
In the world of sports, just about everything is measured. People who work in sports are masters at collecting data. Want to know what Ichiro Suzuki’s batting average is against left handed pitchers with last names starting with the letter R? I’m guessing there is a sports statistician out there who could answer that question for you.
Consider three possible goals we might find in the world of sports (all plucked conveniently from my hometown teams):
- Looking forward to next season, Andrew Wiggins, forward for the Minnesota Timberwolves, sets this goal: To get to the free throw line more times than any other player in the NBA.
- Looking forward to next season, Mike Zimmer, coach of the Minnesota Vikings, sets this goal: To have the top ranked defense in the NFL — both in terms of points allowed and yards allowed.
- Looking forward to next season, Devan Dubnyk, goalie for the Minnesota Wild, sets this goal: To maintain a Save Percentage of 0.900 or higher.
- Looking forward to next season, Paul Molitor, manager of the Minnesota Twins, sets this goal: To win the World Series (that sound you hear is thousands of Twins fans guffawing at the prospect).
When setting goals for your team or organization, remember these goals and ask how they might apply to your organization.
- Like Andrew Wiggins, what do you want your organization to do more of?
- Like Mike Zimmer, what do you want your organization to be best in the world at?
- Like Devan Dubnyk, what is the standard of performance that you want your organization to meet or exceed?
- And like Paul Molitor, what is your World Series trophy — the ultimate goal to end all goals?
When you break it down like this, I think it becomes easier to find your bearings and strive after the things that matter.
Gamification: From Fantasy Sports to Fantasy Government
The only thing bigger than sports is Fantasy Sports. On Monday mornings in the fall, it seems everyone wants to tell you about their fantasy football team. As annoying as that can sometimes get, Fantasy Sports are a wonderful example of gamification in action. For the unfamiliar, gamification describes the concept of taking the mechanics of game playing — such as point scoring, competition, and rules of play — and applying them to another activity that is typically not game-like.
It’s not uncommon to hear about how people are striving to gamify education, shopping, and yes, even government. Gamification is an alluring concept because people by nature enjoy playing games. The act of playing games is inherently fun and engaging. The act of doing homework, shopping for groceries, or renewing a driver’s license is not.
Fantasy Sports are quintessential gamification; they add new game-playing mechanics to the act of watching sports. Perhaps you’ve heard of Fantasy Congress. This the most direct line from Fantasy Sports to Fantasy Government. But how else can Fantasy Sports and gamification inform the work of government? Well, we can gamify digital engagement with government services, like the State of Hawaii has tried to do. This is just one example of many where opportunities are out there. How can you gamify your programs and services to make them inviting and fun?
Go, Fight, Win, Government Leaders!
In closing, I want to mention a fourth area where sports can inspire government: public engagement. We often talk about viewing our constituents as customers. What about viewing them as fans? Sports teams are prolific at building and supporting fan-bases. They create a sense of community, they establish a sense of pride in the places we live and work, and they bring us together in cheering for and chasing shared outcomes.
Aren’t these all things that apply to government too? We want to build communities and bring them together. We want to establish a sense of pride in the places where we live and work. We seek to help people find and pursue shared interests. Now, just like sports fans, people may not always like the things we do. They may second guess some of our decisions. But we’re all in it together when things go well and when they don’t go well. When it comes to engaging the public, we should keep this in mind.
When it comes to everything else we do, remember the lessons outlined above and, no matter your athletic ability, you could be a government champion too.
Adam Giorgi is part of the GovLoop Featured Blogger program, where we feature blog posts by government voices from all across the country (and world!). To see more Featured Blogger posts, click here.
Great analogy Adam. I thoroughly enjoyed reading it and will continue striving to be a Government Champion. Cheers!
Thanks, Alberto!
We can learn other things from sports role models. How not to be diverse and inclusive.
Why are there so few people of color in sports like cycling, softball, kayaking, sailing, bowling, auto racing, water polo, ice hockey and tennis-American Alliance for Health, Physical Education, Recreation and Dance, 2001.
Why is there only 1 black majority owner among 153 teams in the 6 biggest professional major sports in the USA and Canada-The Institute for Diversity and Ethics in. Sports at the University of Central Florida’s College of Business Administration, 2013.
According to the Institute of Diversity and Ethics in Sports:
• Despite the fact that African Americans make up nearly 69% of the players in the NFL, there is not one single African American owner of a NFL team.
• Pakistani-born businessman Shahid Khan, of the Jacksonville Jaguars and Kim Pegula, an Asian American woman of the Buffalo Bills, are the only majority owners of color.
• Paraag Marathe of the San Francisco 49ers is the only team president of color.
• 81% of head coaches are White.
• Only 6 of the head coaches are people of color.
• 70% of the game officials are White.
• 98% of the punters and place kickers are White.
• 60% of the head trainers are White.
• 85% of the team physicians are White.
• 81% of the team administrators are White.
• 88% of the team vice presidents are White.
• 98% of team chief executive officers and presidents are White.
• 79% of general managers and directors of player personnel are White
• For the quarterback position, only 19% of African Americans play this important role.
Of the 862 players on 2016 MLB opening day rosters, only 69 are Black. In other words, Black baseball players make up only 8% of all Major League Baseball players. To put those numbers in perspective, in 1981, 19% of Major League Baseball rosters were Black.
You are right in one respect. Building a diverse and inclusive federal government and society is pure fantasy. Who would want to champion that?